Welcome to Tynga's Reviews — Where the story began. Reviews published before June 2017 may have simplified formatting. Thanks for being here. ♥
Showing posts with label Jean Craighead George. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jean Craighead George. Show all posts

Thursday, April 14, 2016

Ice Whale by Jean Craighead George

I mentioned last week that I was reading this book, and that I thought it was really cool and unique- especially the "whalish" language.  I finished the book and it lived up to it's expectations 100%!

Ice Whale tells the stories of a bowhead whale, Siku, and an Eskimo family.  The story begins in 1848, when a young Eskimo boy, Toozak, witnesses a whale being born.  This is really, really rare.  (In fact, it is only in the last couple of years that anyone has actually witnessed the birth of a right (bowhead) whale.  Toozak's sighting in Ice Whale is fictional.)  Unfortunately, Toozak is young and naive and accidentally leads American whalers right to the whale's pod.  The village shaman tells Toozak that he and his family are now cursed, and must watch over Siku until either a member of the family saves Siku or Siku saves a member of the family.

I thought the curse aspect of the story would involve more mysticism, but alas... it did not.  The book reads much more like "curse" = "banishment."  But there is still the aspect where Siku talks to other whales and to the descendants of Toozak!  That's an awesome detail.  Here's a shot of one page (no spoilers):

Ice Whale Jean Craighead George


Every generation names their first-born "Toozak."  Eventually we get to a generation where the first-born is a girl; even she's named "Emily Toozak" in fulfillment of the shaman's orders.  There was one point in the book where I got just a little turned around with all the Toozaks, but that could just be because I was quite tired while reading it.  It's a middle grades book, so it shouldn't take much brain power, but there's a lot of info in this little gem!


Because the book covers many generations of Toozak's family, we don't get to know any of them very well.  However, their lack of dimensionality doesn't detract from the story- the main story is the whale, and the main "selling point" of the book is the setting and the zoology.  The reader does get to know Siku pretty well.  The anthropomorphism is done very well- I truly felt like I was getting an inside look at whale society.  It didn't read like some little kids' magic animal book; I felt Siku's rhythms and movements and saw the coast of Alaska through his giant eyes.


That brings me to another major winning point with Ice Whale- the setting and zoology.  I get cold easily, and live in the American southeast, but Jean Craighead George's writing made me want to visit Alaska!  The descriptions of the ice and the coast weren't overly wordy but were sweeping.  Also, the way that she works actual factual zoology into the story is excellent.  When I finished the book, I realized I had learned so much about the bowhead whales, and I never knew it was happening during the reading!  (There's also an afterword that clarifies and summarizes a lot of the information from the story.)


Overall, a good book.  Newberry Award winner Jean Craighead George has definitely not lost her touch with prose in this final novel.  The curse aspect combined with the "whalish" makes this a very unique book as well.


Marie

Thursday, April 07, 2016

View From the Middle

Hello all!  I have, unfortunately, not finished a sci-fi/fantasy book this week to share with you.  I am, however, in the midst of two!  May I tell you about them, and about how they are going so far?  Then you can have a full review from me next Thursday!  (In my defense, I am quite pregnant.  I may not have finished a book, but I have finished a nursery.)

First book:  Ice Whale by Jean Craighead George.  This book features a relationship between an Eskimo family and a pod of whales.  In 1848, a young Eskimo boy witnesses the birth of a whale-a very rare sight-and he names the whale.  Then he unwittingly leads a group of whalers to the whale pod.  For generations afterward, the Eskimo and his descendants are cursed until a young girl can rectify the whole situation.  What makes this book extra cool (aside from the Eskimo culture and the curse, both of which are cool enough on their own) is that the story is told in alternating points of view from the Eskimos and the whales!  So there's "whalish" (I just made up that name for the whale language) in the book!  Here's part of a page (no spoilers):

Ice Whale Jean Craighead George


Don't worry- there's not so much whalish that you can't follow the story.  Such a unique thing in a book!


Second book: Ptolemy's Gate by Jonathan Stroud.  It's the "third and final" book in the Bartimaeus "trilogy."  Why all the quotation marks?  Because five years after this was published, Jonathan Stroud ended up writing one more Bartimaeus book... so it's not really the "final" book in the "trilogy" as the back of the book proclaims.  I'm not complaining- I love, love, love the snarky dry-humored Bartimaeus and look forward to the series continuing at least one more book!  I'm listening to this one on CD in my car and it's such fun.  I literally laugh out loud at parts!  Poor Nathaniel the magician, bumbling through his government bureaucracy job while trying to keep a handle on his often-wayward djinni, Bartimaeus.   Also in this book: Kitty.  She's not gone after all!  She's so super smart; I totally enjoy reading about her jobs and her research, and how she manages to get so much done in a time period when girls/women were expected to be quiet and keep home.  In this installment, the three of them will end up working together to try to create world peace between magicians and the public and djinnis.  I'm only about halfway through, so I have no clue if they survive each others' company, or succeed at their task!  ;)


So, that's what I'm up to!  I hope everyone has a great week.  I'll be back next Thursday with a legit review, I promise!


Marie

Join the Inner Circle

Free 2026 Reading Bingo printable, occasional freebies and new-release updates for all Tynga Publishing reading journals.