Welcome to Tynga's Reviews — Where the story began. Reviews published before June 2017 may have simplified formatting. Thanks for being here. ♥

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Review: Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1) by Sloane St. James

Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1)

Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1)

by Sloane St. James

★★★★★

Read: November 4, 2026

450 pages


I went in expecting a contemporary romance set in a tattoo shop. Friends-to-lovers, age gap, slow burn — safe territory. What I got was a man so devoted and so absolutely unhinged that I had to put the book down at least twice just to process the lengths he was willing to go to. And somehow — somehow — I rooted for him through every insane second of it.

Logan is not your typical book boyfriend. He's quiet, controlled, and deeply artistic. He paints, he tattoos, he notices every detail about the woman he's been in love with for three years. He's also a certifiable lunatic who will architect reality itself before he risks saying three words to her face. The contrast between how far he'll go behind the scenes and how paralyzed he is in front of her is what makes him magnetic instead of insufferable. He's brave enough to commit a felony but too scared to say I love you. When I tell you this man has schemes — I mean schemes. You're not ready.

Kelly is the heart of this book in ways that crept up on me. She's grieving her father — a legend in the tattoo world — and she's carrying that loss while trying to build her own name, not ride on his. She's smart, she's stubborn, and she has incredible instincts about almost everyone around her. When the truth finally comes out — and oh, it comes out — she doesn't crumble. She detonates. The confrontation scene is twenty-five pages long and it is magnificent. I will say nothing else about it. Just know it earned this book its fifth star.

The father's letters are the quiet emotional spine holding everything together. I was not prepared. I don't think I'll get over it.

The slow burn earns every page it takes. Small escalations keep the tension alive without dragging, and by the time these two finally crash into each other, you've been holding your breath for so long the release is almost violent. The pacing never bored me — something is always shifting, always tightening.

There is a thriller thread woven through the second half that elevated this book from great romance to great book. My gut was screaming about a certain character long before the plot confirmed it, and when it hits, it hits hard. The stakes go from emotional to life-threatening in a way that feels earned, not forced.

Sloane St. James walked a razor's edge with this book. Logan is objectively unhinged, and she never flinches from that. She doesn't soften him into a misunderstood hero or excuse his behavior with a sad backstory. She lets him be exactly what he is and makes you love him anyway. And Kelly is the reason it all works — because she's not a passive recipient of his obsession. She's his equal. She matches him in fire and stubbornness and sheer force of will, and when she makes her choice, she makes it with her eyes wide open.

I already started reading Casper's book. 🤭

Sidenote, how amazing was the Foxx bourbon mention?!

Tropes: friends-to-lovers · age gap · slow burn · obsessive MMC · tattoo artist · manipulation as love language · grief and healing · suspense/thriller elements · found family · Deaf representation

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Review: Bikers' Pretty Little Property: A why choose dark romcom (Song-Smith Sequel Series Book 1) by Cate Roi

Bikers' Pretty Little Property: A why choose dark romcom (Song-Smith Sequel Series Book 1)

Bikers' Pretty Little Property: A why choose dark romcom (Song-Smith Sequel Series Book 1)

by Cate Roi

★★½☆☆ (2.75)

Read: November 11, 2026

316 pages


Thank you to the author for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

I wanted to love this one. A dark rom-com where a black cat mechanic who tells everyone exactly where to shove it, a golden retriever biker prez who refuses to hear the word no, and a shy hacker who's been texting her under a fake name for two years? Sign me up. And some of it delivered.

Will is the heart of this book for me. He spent two years keeping Viv fed, housed and alive from the other side of a phone without ever giving her his name, and that kind of quiet, sideways devotion is my weakness. Every time he blushed his way through a scene, I melted a little. I also loved that his prosthetic leg is part of who he is without being his whole story. He's desirable, he's capable, he has his wheelchair days, and Viv's first instinct is to geek out over the hydraulics. That's disability rep done with warmth. The cast is wonderfully diverse too, with several characters of Filipino and Korean descent, and you can feel the author writing from her own background in those details.

Viv's voice is a delight. She thinks in car parts, and every POV has its own rhythm, which I really appreciated. Kurt is pure chaos in flip-flops, and some of the funniest moments in the book are his. Will's thinks in computer parts and Trav is all mushy inside despite his gruff exterior.

But I struggled. This is sold as first in the series, readable on its own, and technically it is, but the beginning throws the whole extended family from the Song-Smith books at you at once. Siblings, in-laws, an old prez, a full crew and a history. It was overwhelming. I didn't have the family tree straight until past the halfway point, and a lot of moments clearly meant to land as reunions just left me asking who these people were. If you haven't read the earlier books, I'd honestly start there.

The bigger issue for me was the why choose itself. Two of the four men are a couple (and if you know me, you know I love MM in books!), and their connection with Viv never went beyond attraction. There's plenty of group spice, but without feelings underneath it, the dynamic felt more like regular gang-bangs than a relationship I could root for. Some emotional beats resolved much faster than they were built, and forgiveness got handed to people who hadn't earned it. Also, as someone with a medical background, a lot of details pulled me right out of the story.

There's a fun book in here. The humor works, and Will deserves the world. If you've already read Cate Roi's earlier books, I think you'll enjoy seeing everyone again much more than I did. It just didn't come together for me.

Trigger warnings: foster care · minor sexual abuse (past) · drugging · dubious consent · memory loss · coma · carbon monoxide poisoning · murder · dismemberment · fire · loss of limb · death of a parent · poverty · drug dealing · gun violence · homophobia

Tropes: why choose · MM between love interests · Motorcycle club · mechanic FMC · hacker MMC · anonymous texter · he fell first · golden retriever x black cat · age gap · found family · small town · second generation

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Friday, November 13, 2026

Review: Graves by Katelyn Taylor

Graves

Graves

by Katelyn Taylor

★★★☆☆

Read: October 18, 2026

457 pages


This book has a lot going on. Twin mercenaries, a girl caught between them, a stalker dynamic that isn't quite what it seems, and enough emotional damage in the backstory that could easily fill three novels. The bones are there. The ambition is there. I just never fully sank into it.

Dominic and Zayden are interesting separately — Dominic with his possessive intensity and Zayden with his unhingedness and the protective edge he hides behind cruelty. The dynamic between the brothers has real teeth. There's a competitiveness layered over something deeper, something neither of them can name, and when the book leans into that tension, it works. The knife scenes, the cemetery, the moments where the violence between them isn't really about her at all — those have weight, but they disappointed me at times, especially Dominic.

Blake is in an impossible position, and Taylor doesn't shy away from it. She's sandwiched between two men who are fundamentally dangerous to her and to each other, and the moments where she holds her own are genuinely satisfying. But there's an information asymmetry between Blake and the reader that kept pulling me out. We know things she doesn't — about who's been protecting her, about why — and waiting for her to catch up felt more like stalling than tension.

The backstory, when it finally lands, is devastating. These boys were forged in something genuinely awful, and the reveal of how they got there hits hard. I just wish the book had let me sit with it longer instead of accelerating into the final act. Hers is equally has terrible, but it's at least processed.

The spice has heat and the darker elements are committed — Taylor doesn't flinch from what she's writing. But I never felt that gut-deep pull, the thing that makes me rearrange my day to keep listening. I put it aside for six weeks and picking it back up felt like a decision, not a compulsion. For me, that says more than any specific criticism could.

It's a solid read. If you love dark romance with twin dynamics and morally grey MMCs who were never given a chance to be anything else, I'm sure you will enjoy it. Honestly, I find it hard to pinpoint why I didn't enjoy it more. The world Taylor's building across her books has real potential, and I'll still read Graves & Griggs because I already own it but this one just didn't own me the way I wanted it to.

Tropes: twin MMCs · stalker romance · dark romance · possessive MMC · knife play · Peach play · DP · mob/hitman · forced proximity · breeding kink · captor/captive elements · shared FMC · childhood trauma

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Review: Iced Out (Leighton U, #1) by C.E. Ricci

Iced Out (Leighton U, #1)

Iced Out (Leighton U, #1)

by C.E. Ricci

★★★★☆

Read: April 26, 2025

358 pages


Hockey romance is always hit or miss for me, and not only was this one a hit — it was kind of a revelation, lol. I realized that all the hockey romance books I’ve really loved have MM in them (either straight-up MM or why choose with MM). Apparently, that’s the secret sauce for me, because every MF one I’ve read? Either a DNF or I didn’t bother continuing the series.

I listened to this on audio, and both narrators did an amazing job bringing the characters to life!

Iced Out is a college sports romance where the two MCs go from longtime rivals to reluctant teammates. They’ve despised each other for years playing on opposite teams — even came to blows more than once. Now they’re stuck playing for the same school... on the same line. And since the team is on a losing streak, they have to make it work.

I loved the nonstop banter between these two grumps. Even when they’re finally getting along, they can’t help but tease and bicker. It was so entertaining!

Here are some tropes you can expect:

-Enemies to Lovers
-Forced Proximity (they share a room on the road)
-MM Romance
-Grumpy x Grumpy
-Secret Relationship
-Slow Burn
-Bi-Awakening

I’ll definitely be picking up book 2!

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Review: Dolls & Daggers (Serial Killer Book Club #1) by D.L. Darby

Dolls & Daggers (Serial Killer Book Club #1)

Dolls & Daggers (Serial Killer Book Club #1)

by D.L. Darby

★★★★½ (4.5)

Read: October 28, 2026

378 pages

Source: Personal library


Finally! A dark rom-com that's genuinely both. I've been duped by a few books with dark rom-com-ish covers but were actually dark romance, so Dolls & Daggers made my heart sing.

Dove is a 5-foot pink-and-lace ray of sunshine in four-inch heels, the star journalist who saved a failing paper by covering a vigilante serial killer who hunts predators. Small detail: she's the killer. Enter Ren, a tall, gorgeous, arrogant new hire who wants her column and is a little too obsessed with the Doll. What follows is a prank war so petty and unhinged I was cackling on my walks to work. Salt. Hair dye. A furry innocent bystander. Snacks you will never look at the same way again.

What I loved most is that the rivalry actually stays a rivalry. So many enemies-to-lovers books give up the fight in the first chapters. These two keep sabotaging each other well after things heat up, and every inch of ground they give feels earned.

Under all that chaos there are two deeply wounded people, and the author handles their trauma with real weight without losing the humor.

Why not 5 stars? One plot thread gets swept under the rug way too easily, and it bugged me. Maybe book 2 will pick it up. (And I am SO ready for that side couple to get their own story.)

🎧 Audiobook notes: Lucy Rivers and Aaron Shedlock did an amazing job. Lucy's bubbly, high-pitched Dove grated on my nerves, but that's exactly the point. It's perfect for the character and nothing like her usual voice. Fair warning: their pacing is very different, so I listened at 1.25x the whole way, instead of my usual 1.7x speed.

Tropes: Rivals to lovers · Workplace romance · Vigilante FMC / she's the villain · Morally grey heroine · Secret identity · Obsessed MMC · Touch her and die · Prank war · Size difference (tiny FMC, tall MMC) · Found family · Trauma healing

⚠️ Check the content warnings: child sexual abuse/grooming (past), graphic murder, torture, gore, violence, and spice.

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Review: Threshing Day (The Empyrean, #3.5) by Rebecca Yarros

Threshing Day (The Empyrean, #3.5)

Threshing Day (The Empyrean, #3.5)

by Rebecca Yarros

★★★★★

Read: October 11, 2026

224 pages


I didn't expect a collection of short stories to pull me back into the Empyrean world this hard. But here I am, completely wrecked by a book with no central plot, no romance arc, and no villain to hate (well there was Alic I guess 🤣) — just twelve bonding stories that quietly rearranged everything I thought I knew about characters I've been reading for three books.

That's what Threshing Day does. It takes the riders you already love — or haven't forgiven yet — and strips them back to the moment before they became who you know. Before the wars, the betrayals, the alliances. Before any of it. Just a person on a field, facing a creature that sees straight through them.

And every dragon asks the same question, in a different way: who are you, really?

Some answers are defiant. Some are devastating. Some made me laugh until I ached. One made me want to reach into the pages and hold someone, because I had no idea — none — what they were carrying underneath the composure the main books showed me. Yarros doesn't just fill in backstory here. She rewrites how you'll see these people when you go back. The steady ones weren't always steady. The brave ones weren't always sure they wanted to survive.

What surprised me most is how different each bonding feels. Some are earned through combat, others through stubbornness, one through pure chaos and mutual insults up a tree. And then there are the ones that aren't earned at all — they're recognized. Grief meeting grief. Loss meeting loss. A dragon saying not prove yourself but let's carry this together. Those are the ones that stay in your chest.

The collector's edition is gorgeous — full color dragon illustrations at the start of each story — and the audiobook production is smart: each story gets its own narrator, so every rider has a distinct voice. For a book this short, the care that went into the presentation says everything about what this collection means to the series.

If you've read the Empyrean series, this isn't optional. It will change your reread. And when book four finally comes — whenever it's coming — this is the emotional primer you didn't know you needed.

Tropes: found family · sacrifice · chosen bonds · grief and survival
Trigger warnings: Violence, death, suicidal ideation

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Join the Inner Circle

Free 2026 Reading Bingo printable, occasional freebies and new-release updates for all Tynga Publishing reading journals.