Welcome to Tynga's Reviews — Where the story began. Reviews published before June 2017 may have simplified formatting. Thanks for being here. ♥

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Review: Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1) by Sloane St. James

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Tynga's Reviews! ♥

Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1)

Of Ink and Alchemy (Black Rabbit, #1)

by Sloane St. James

★★★★★

Read: November 4, 2026

450 pages


I went in expecting a contemporary romance set in a tattoo shop. Friends-to-lovers, age gap, slow burn — safe territory. What I got was a man so devoted and so absolutely unhinged that I had to put the book down at least twice just to process the lengths he was willing to go to. And somehow — somehow — I rooted for him through every insane second of it.

Logan is not your typical book boyfriend. He's quiet, controlled, and deeply artistic. He paints, he tattoos, he notices every detail about the woman he's been in love with for three years. He's also a certifiable lunatic who will architect reality itself before he risks saying three words to her face. The contrast between how far he'll go behind the scenes and how paralyzed he is in front of her is what makes him magnetic instead of insufferable. He's brave enough to commit a felony but too scared to say I love you. When I tell you this man has schemes — I mean schemes. You're not ready.

Kelly is the heart of this book in ways that crept up on me. She's grieving her father — a legend in the tattoo world — and she's carrying that loss while trying to build her own name, not ride on his. She's smart, she's stubborn, and she has incredible instincts about almost everyone around her. When the truth finally comes out — and oh, it comes out — she doesn't crumble. She detonates. The confrontation scene is twenty-five pages long and it is magnificent. I will say nothing else about it. Just know it earned this book its fifth star.

The father's letters are the quiet emotional spine holding everything together. I was not prepared. I don't think I'll get over it.

The slow burn earns every page it takes. Small escalations keep the tension alive without dragging, and by the time these two finally crash into each other, you've been holding your breath for so long the release is almost violent. The pacing never bored me — something is always shifting, always tightening.

There is a thriller thread woven through the second half that elevated this book from great romance to great book. My gut was screaming about a certain character long before the plot confirmed it, and when it hits, it hits hard. The stakes go from emotional to life-threatening in a way that feels earned, not forced.

Sloane St. James walked a razor's edge with this book. Logan is objectively unhinged, and she never flinches from that. She doesn't soften him into a misunderstood hero or excuse his behavior with a sad backstory. She lets him be exactly what he is and makes you love him anyway. And Kelly is the reason it all works — because she's not a passive recipient of his obsession. She's his equal. She matches him in fire and stubbornness and sheer force of will, and when she makes her choice, she makes it with her eyes wide open.

I already started reading Casper's book. 🤭

Sidenote, how amazing was the Foxx bourbon mention?!

Tropes: friends-to-lovers · age gap · slow burn · obsessive MMC · tattoo artist · manipulation as love language · grief and healing · suspense/thriller elements · found family · Deaf representation

Amazon.caAmazon.comGoodreads


Track your own reading journey ✦

Discover Tynga Publishing Reading Journals

Hey, I'm Tynga! Montreal-based mom of two and lifelong book lover. I started this blog in 2009 reviewing PNR and UF, and over the years my shelves expanded into Romantasy, Dark Romance, and Dark Rom-Com. This blog is the archive. These days, my bookish life lives mostly on TikTok. I also create reading journals through Tynga Publishing — designed by a reader, for readers.

Tiktok | Instagram | My Reading Journals

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Join the Inner Circle

Free 2026 Reading Bingo printable, occasional freebies and new-release updates for all Tynga Publishing reading journals.